Investigating the Realism or Idealism of Iran's Legislative Criminal Policy

• Ahmadreza Vanaki Islamic Azad University
• karim Salehi Islamic Azad University
• Meysam Nematollahi Islamic Azad University.

Palabras clave: Idealism and realism, restricted criminal policy, controversial criminal policy, Dynamic fiqh, Shiite theology.

Resumen

This document addresses problems and questions that arise about realism or idealism in the context of the criminal policy of the double legislature in Iran, with the aim of revealing the available skills and capacities of the laws that govern the matter. Has the Iranian lawmaker followed an idealistic criminal policy? Is realism what is necessary for a dimensional criminal policy in Iran's criminal laws? What is the solution to the transition from religious idealism to a realist perspective preserving the status quo? What is certain is that, when examining existing criminal law, criminal policy based on religious idealism and dimensional realism can be seen in terms of criminological data; from the oldest data in criminal law to the latest criminal paradigms. Methodologically, documentary research technique and legal hermeneutics were used. It is concluded that traditional theologically based laws and sharia-based oversight bodies need a new dynamism and a new ijtihad. In this study, the dimensions of the subject and the form of transcendence from idealism to realism are given while preserving religious values.

Citas

ARDABILI, Mohammad Ali. 2013. General Criminal Law. Mizan Publications. Tehran, Irán.

IRVANIAN, Amir. 2013. General Theory of Criminal Policy. Shahrdarshan Publications. Tehran, Irán.

TEBIT, Mark. 2007. Philosophy of Law, translated by Hossein Rezaei Khavari. Razavi University of Islamic Sciences Publishing. Mashhad, Irán.

JAVANMARD, Behrooz. 2014. Zero Tolerance of Strict Penal Policy for Small Crimes. Mizan Publications. Tehran, Irán.

CHINHANGARU, Austin. 2015. Fundamentals of Philosophy of Law, translated by Hibatullah Nejandi Manesh. Khorsandi Publications. Tehran, Irán.

HAR-AMELI, Mohammad Ibn Hassan. 1412. AH, Shiite means. Al-Bayt Institute (AS). Qom, Irán.

KHALEGHI, Ali. 2015. Criminal Procedure. Shahrdarshan Publications. Tehran, Irán.

RAHMANI, Mohammad. 2015. Fundamentals of Criminal Policy at the Level of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Majd Publications. Tehran, Irán.

AGRICULTURE, Abbas. 2014. Brief Description of Islamic Penal Code. Phoenix Publications. Tehran, Irán.

SURI, Ahmad. 2016. Criminal Psychology. University of Law Enforcement Sciences. Tehran, Irán.

SHARIATI, Mohammad Sadegh. 2001. Jurisprudential and Legal Review of the Expediency Discernment Council. Bustan Ketab Publications. Qom, Irán.

EBADI, Shirin. 1994. History and Documents of Human Rights in Iran. Roshanfekran Publications. Tehran, Irán.

ABDOLRAHMANI, Reza; HABIBZADEH, Ashab. 2015. An Introduction to the Sociology of Punishment. University of Law Enforcement Publications. Tehran, Irán.

ACTIVE, Tayebeh. 2014. The Nature of Crime. Negah Bineh Publications. Tehran, Irán.

FOUCAULT, Michel. 1999. Care and Punishment, translated by Niko Sarkhosh and Afshin Jahan Dideh. Ney Publishing. Tehran, Irán.

QOMI, Mirza Abolghasem. 1999. Laws of Principles. Islamic Scientific School Publications. Tehran, Irán.

KARKHIRAN, Mohammad Hossein. 2013. The most complete set of Islamic Penal Code. Rah-e Novin Publications. Tehran, Irán.

GOLDOZIAN, Iraj. 2015. Islamic Penal Code. Majd Publications. Tehran, Irán.

LOTFABADI, Hossein. 2014. Developmental Psychology 2. Samat Publications. Tehran, Irán.

MAKAREM SHIRAZI, Nasser. 2002. New Inquiries. Amir al-Mo'menin School Publications (AS). Qom, Irán.

MCGRAYER, James. 2011. Understanding Psychology and Crime, translated by Soghari Ebrahimi Ghavam. University of Law Enforcement Publishing. Tehran, Irán.

MORAWATS, Thomas 2012. Philosophy of Fundamental Rights and Functions, translated by Behrouz Jandaghi. Hozeh and University Press. Tehran, Irán.

MOUSAVI KHOMEINI, Ruhollah. 1985. Sahifa Noor, Imam Khomeini Lecture Series. Ministry of Islamic Guidance. Tehran, Irán.

MARTY, Mir Ray Delmas. 2014. Major Systems of Criminal Policy, translated by Ali Hossein Najafi Abrandabadi. Mizan Publications. Tehran, Irán.

NAJAFI, Mohammad Hassan. 1984. Jawahar al-Kalam. Islamic Magazine. Tehran, Irán.

JAVAN ARASTEH, Hossein. 2003. “Constitution and Principles of Religious Sovereignty in Legislation” In: Quarterly Journal of Islamic Government. Vol. 8, Num. 28, pp. 72-105.

JAHANGIRI, Mohsen. 2008. “Dynamic Jurisprudence” In: Theology and Law. Vol. 27, pp. 3-12.

KHORASANI, Reza. 2013. “Methodology of government jurisprudence in the sphere of Imam Khomeini's jurisprudential, political thought” In: Research Journal of the Islamic Revolution, Hamadan University. Vol. 9, pp. 47-68.

DABIRNIA, Alireza; NAGHAVI, Fatemeh Sadat. 2018. “Implementation of the Legislation Process in the Islamic Republic of Iran with Legislative Theory as Planning for the Implementation of Divine Laws” In: Journal of Public Law. Vol. 7 Num. 19, pp. 113-134.

FEYZ, Alireza; HOSSEINI SANANI, Batoul. 2008. “Study of the Factors of the Dynamics of Jurisprudence” In: Research Journal of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law. Vol. Num. 1, pp. 97-133.

KAABI, Abbas; FATTAHI ZAFAR GHANDI, Ali; BAHADORI JAHROMI, Ali. 2008. Speeches in Islamic Public Law, General Policy of the System, Strategies for Promoting the Islamic Legislative System ". (16/2/98). Available online. In: http: "jon.ir/u8zv. Date of consultation: 15/12/2019.