Linguistic Episteme as a Discourse-Generating Mechanism of Speech Activity. / Episteme lingüístico como mecanismo generador de discursos en la actividad del habla.

  • NIKOLAY ALEFIRENKO Belgorod State Research University
  • MARAL NURTAZINA The L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University, Nur-Sultan, Kazakhstan
  • ZUKHRA SHAKHPUTOVA The L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University, Nur-Sultan, Kazakhstan




The author's version of the new linguistic episteme formation – linguistic postmodernism – in terms of synergy of philosophy, linguistic and cultural studies is presented. An attempt is made to substantiate the linguistic episteme as a product of the synergistic convergence of ideas of an entire era in the development of the science of language in the form of (a) a hidden and deep-seated model of thinking that forms the corresponding linguistic picture of the world; (b) a certain original strategy of scientific and cognitive activity (a peculiar set of methodological principles that the linguistic community is guided by in their research practice).



Se presenta la versión del autor de la nueva formación de la episteme lingüístico - posmodernismo lingüístico - en términos de sinergia de la filosofía, los estudios lingüísticos y culturales. Se intenta fundamentar la como producto de la convergencia sinérgica de ideas de toda una era en el desarrollo de la ciencia del lenguaje en forma de (a) un modelo de pensamiento oculto y profundamente arraigado que forma la correspondiente imagen lingüística del mundo; (b) una cierta estrategia original de actividad científica y cognitiva (un conjunto peculiar de principios metodológicos por los que se guía la comunidad lingüística en su práctica investigadora).


ALEFIRENKO, NF (2009). "Living word: Problems of functional lexicology." M.: Flint: Science.

ALEFIRENKO, N, & NURTAZINA, M (2018). "Metaphorical Discourse: in Search for the Essence of Speech Imagery." Cuadernos de Rusistica Espanola, pp.49-65.

ATLAS, JD (2005). "Logic, meaning, and conversation: semantic underdeterminacy, implicature, and their interface." Oxford: Oxford University Press.

BENTON, MA (2016). "Knowledge and evidence you should have had." Episteme-a Journal of individual and social epistemology, 13, (4), pp.471-479.

BEN-YAMI, H, CARSTON, R & WERNING, M (2018). "Introduction to the 2nd Synthese Special Issue: trends in philosophy of language and mind." Synthese, 195(8), pp.3289–3291.

BERGER, PL & LUCKMANN, T (1967). "The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge." Penguin Books.

BOURDIEU, P (1988). "L’Ontologie politique de Martin Heidegger." Paris: Minuit.

BRADLEY, D (2018). Philosophers should prefer simpler theories. Philosophical studies, 175(12), pp.3049-3067.

BRENTANO, F (1995). "Psychology from an Empirical Standpoint", pp.88-89.

BUENO, O (2017). "Thinking about Science, reflecting on Art: Bringing Aesthetics and Philosophy of Science Together (co-edited with George Daby, Steven French, and Dean Rickles)", London: Routledge.

BYBEE, JL (2010). "Language, usage and cognition." Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

CAMP, E (2006). "Contextualism, metaphor, and what is said." Mind and Language, 21(3), pp.280-309.

CAPONE, A (2017). "Rethinking Language, Mind, and Meaning." Australian journal of linguistics, 37(1), pp.112-120.

CARNAP, R (1980). "Studies in inductive logic and probability", University of California Press.

CHEMERO, A & SILBERSTEIN, M (2008). "After the philosophy of mind: Replacing scholasticism with science." Philosophy of Science, 75(5), pp.1–27.

CHOMSKY, N (2006). "Language and Mind."

CLARK, A (2016). "Surfing uncertainty: Prediction, action, and the embodied mind." New York: Oxford University Press.

COLOMBO, M & WRIGHT, C (2017). "Explanatory pluralism: An unrewarding prediction error for free energy theorists." Brain and Cognition, 112(4), pp.3-12.

CRAVER, C (2007). "Explaining the brain." Oxford: Oxford University Press.

CUMMINS, R (1994). "Interpretational semantics", Mental representation: A reader. Oxford: Blackwell.

DAVIDSON, D (1984). "Convention and communication." Synthese, 59(1), pp.3-17.

DAVIS, W (2003). "Meaning, expression, and thought." Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

DE HAAN, F (1999). "Evidentiality and Epistemic Modality: Setting Boundaries." Southwest Journal of Linguistics, 18(6), pp.83-101.

DIJK, TA (2010). "Critical discourse analysis."

DELEUZE, G (1974). "Logique de la sensation." Paris: Les Editions de Minuit.

DERRIDA, J (2002). "Ethics, Institutions, and the Right to Philosophy."

DILTHEY, W (2002). "The Formation of the Historical World in the Human Sciences", pp.16–70.

ENDO, T (2013). "Epistemic stance in Mandarin conversation: The positions and functions of wo juede ‘I think’." Chinese Discourse and Interaction: Theory and Practice, pp.12–34.

FIELD, H (1977). "Logic, meaning and conceptual role." Journal of Philosophy, 74(69), pp.379-409.

FODOR, J (1990). "A theory of content and other essays." Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.

FOKKEMA, DW (1986). "The Semantic & Syntactic Organisation of Postmodern Texts." Approaching Postmodernism, Philadelphia: Univ. of Utrecht Press, pp.81-98.

FOUCAULT, M (1966). "Les Mots et les Choses." Une Archéologie des Sciences Humaines.

FRANKL, V (2000). "Man's search for ultimate meaning." Perseus Pub.

FUKUYAMA, YF (1992). "The End of History and the Last Man." Free Press.

GARFINKEL, H (2002). "Ethnomethodology's Program", Lanham MD, Rowman and Littlefield.

GARROD, S & ANDERSON, A (1987). "Saying what you mean in dialogue: A study in conceptual and semantic co-ordination." Cognition, 27(13), pp.126-181.

GAUKER, C (2013). "Inexplicit thoughts." Oxford: Oxford University Press.

GENDLIN, ET (1992). The wider role of bodily sense in thought and language. In Sheets-Johnstone, M. Giving the body its due. Albany: State University of New York Press.

GOODFELLOW, I, BENGIO, Y & COURVILLE, A (2016). "Deep learning." Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

GRAYLING, A (1996). Epistemology. The Blackwell companion to philosophy, Oxford, pp.38-63.

GRICE, HP (1957). "Meaning." Philosophical Review, 66(42), pp.377-388.

HABERMAS, J (1985). "Der Philosophische Diskurs der Moderne."

HARRÉ, HR (1993). Social being", Oxford: Blackwell.

HECK, R (2014). "Semantics and context-dependence: Towards a Strawsonian account." Metasemantics: New essays on the foundations of meaning Oxford: Oxford University Press.

HEIM, I (1982). "File change semantics and the familiarity theory of definiteness." Meaning, use and interpretation of language, Berlin: De Gruyter.

HOHWY, J (2015). "The neural organ explains the mind." Open MIND, Frankfurt am Main: MIND Group.

HUSSERL, E (1973). "Logical Investigations."

IMBERT, C, MULDOON, R, SPRENGER, J & ZOLLMAN, K (2014). "Introduction, SI of Synthese “The collective dimension of science”." Synthese,191(25), pp.1–2.

ISAC, D & REISS, C (2008). "I-Language: An introduction to linguistics as cognitive science." Oxford: Oxford University Press.

JACKENDOFF, R (2012). "A User's Guide to Thought and Meaning." Oxford: Oxford University Press.

JUAN, VS (2016). "Does language matter for implicit theory of mind? The effects of epistemic verb training on implicit and explicit false-belief understanding." Cognitive development, pp.19-32.

KANT, I (2008). "The Critique of Pure Reason."

KÄRKKÄINEN, E (2003). "Epistemic stance in English conversation." Amsterdam: John Benjamins.

KELLY, GA (1991). "The psychology of personal constructs: A theory of personality." London: Routledge.

KING, J (2014). "Speaker intentions in context." Nous, 48(2), pp.219-237.

KRISTEVA, J (1984). "Revolution in poetic Language", N.Y.: Columbia Univ. Press.

LARSON, RK & SEGAL, GMA (1995). "Knowledge of meaning: An introduction to semantic theory." Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

LEONTYEV, D.A (2003). "Psychology of Meaning: Nature, Structure and Dynamics of Semantic Reality", rev.ed. M.: Smysl.

LÉVI-STRAUSS, C (2005). "Myth and Meaning."

LEWERENTZ, L & MARSCHALL, B (2018). "Metasemantics, intentions and circularity." Synthese, 195(4), pp.1667–1679

LOAR, B (1981). "Meaning and mind." Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

LOCKE, D (2017). "Implicature and non-local pragmatic encroachment." Synthese, 194(2), pp.631-654.

LUPYAN, G (2015). "Cognitive penetrability of perception in the age of prediction: Predictive systems are penetrable systems." Review of Philosophy and Psychology, 6(4), pp547-569.

LURIYA, AR (2007). "Lectures on general psychology."

LYOTARD, JF (1997). "Postmodern Fables", Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

MACPHERSON, F (2017). "The relationship between cognitive penetration and predictive coding." Consciousness and Cognition, 47(22), pp.6-16.

MATURANA, H (1984). "The tree of knowledge. Biological basis of human understanding."

METZINGER, T & WIESE, W (2017). "Philosophy and predictive processing." MIND Group: Frankfurt am Main.

MILLIKAN, R (1998). "Language conventions made simple." Journal of Philosophy, 95(4), pp161-180.

MORAVCSIK, J (1998). "Meaning, creativity, and the partial inscrutability of the human mind." Stanford: Center for the Study of Language and Information.

NIINILUOTO, I (2016). "Logical Tools for Human Thinking: Jaakko Hintikka (1929-2015)." Journal for general philosophy of science, 47(2), pp.267-276.

NUTTIN, J (1984). "Motivation, planning, and action." A relational theory of behavior dynamics: Transl. Leuven: Leuven University Press.

PIAGET, J (2000). "Commentary on Vygotsky." New Ideas in Psychology, 18(1), pp.241–259.

PINKER, S (2007). "The Stuff of Thought: Language as a Window into Human Nature." Language, Cognition, and Human Nature: Selected Articles, Gardners Books.

POPPER, KR (1994). "The myth of the framework: in defense of science and rationality."

PSILLOS, S & RUTTKAMP-BLOEM, E (2017). "Scientific realism: quo vadis? Introduction: new thinking about scientific realism." Synthese, S.I.: New Thinking about Scientific Realism.

PUTNAM, H (1974). "Philosophy of language and philosophy of science." PSA1974, East Lansing: Philosophy of Science Association.

ROBERTS, C (2004). "Context in dynamic interpretation." The handbook of pragmatics, Oxford: Blackwell.

SCHIFFER, S (1993). "Actual-language relations." Philosophical Perspectives, 7(6), pp.231-258.

SIMS, A (2016). "A problem of scope for the free energy principle as a theory of cognition." Philosophical Psychology, 29(7), pp.967-980.

SPAULDING, S (2018). "Mindreading beyond belief: A more comprehensive conception of how we understand others." Philosophy compass, 13(11).

STANFORD, K (2016). "Underdetermination of scientific theory." The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.

STANLEY, J (2005). "Semantics in context." Contextualism in philosophy: Knowledge, meaning, and truth., Oxford: Oxford University Press.

VAN GELDER, T (1998). "What might cognition be, if not computation?" Journal of Philosophy, 92(26), pp.345-381.

VETTER, P & NEWEN, A (2014). Varieties of cognitive penetration in visual perception. Consciousness and Cognition, 27(24), pp.62-75.

VYGOTSKY, LS (1986). "Thought and Language", Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press.

UNGERER, F & SCHMID, HJ (1996). "An Introduction to Cognitive Linguistics." Harlow: Longman.

WATZLAWICK, P (1992). "Wirklichkeitsanpassung oder angepasste “Wirklichkeit? Konstruktivismus und Psychotherapie." Einfuhrung in den Konstruktivismus, Munchen: Piper VerlagGmbH, pp.89-107.

WIERZBICKA, A (1994). "Semantics and Epistemology: the Meaning of “Evidentials” in a Cross-Linguistic Perspective." Language Science, 16(1), pp.81-137.

WIGGINS, D (1997)." Languages as social objects." Philosophy, 72(22), pp.499-524.

WILLIAMS, D & COLLING, L (2017). "From symbols to icons: the return of resemblance in the cognitive neuroscience revolution." Synthese, S.I.: Neuroscience and its philosophy, 195(6), pp.1941-1967.

WITTGENSTEIN, LJ (1986). "Philosophical investigations", Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

Cómo citar
ALEFIRENKO, N., NURTAZINA, M., & SHAKHPUTOVA, Z. (2020). Linguistic Episteme as a Discourse-Generating Mechanism of Speech Activity. / Episteme lingüístico como mecanismo generador de discursos en la actividad del habla. Utopía Y Praxis Latinoamericana, 25(1), 438-463. Recuperado a partir de