The Hagarism at Patricia Crone and Michael Cook, A com- parative commentary study between Western Christian thought and facts of Islam
Resumen
The research included a comparative commentary study between Western Chris- tian thought and facts of Islam by the book of historians Patricia Crone and Mi- chael Cook: (Hagarism: The Making of the Islamic World) it is on the early history of the religion of Islam, in which the authors gave a different conception of Islam based primarily on Judaism and Christianity and excluding Islamic sources and relying instead on non-Islamic sources in a failed attempt to obliterate Islamic his- tory and invent a new history that agrees with their ideology. The study indicates the lack of objectivity of the researchers in their selection of these sources, because they are highly questionable due to the inaccuracy of the transfer of information and the intertwined and the many questions that revolve around some of the names that came in their book, contrary to the traditional Islamic historical perception contained in our Islamic books, as researchers are trying in their work (Hagarism) and in other works questioning the Muslim thoughts, including the name of Islam. They said that there is no evidence of the designation of Islam in the time of the Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him), This name appeared for the first time in 691 AD, but the emergence of the original manuscripts of the messages of the Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him) to some Kings especially to the king Amuqawqas, which was recently found in a monastery in Egypt, carried the name of Islam and it refuted authors allegations and showed the weakness of the sources that they have adopted in their claims.Citas
Ali, K., 2006. Hagarism: The Story of a Book Written by Infidels for Infidels. baltimorechronicle.com/ 2006/042606AliKhan. shtml. (7 / 4/2019).
Al-Jiblawi, A., 2008. The New Anglo-Saxon Orientalism An article in early Islam, Patricia Crown and Michael Cook as a model. Al-Kamel Verlog. pp. 149-152. (In Arabic).
Al-Naim, A., 1997. Orientalism in the Biography of the Prophet A historical study of the views of Watt-Brockelmann-Volhosen compared to the Islamic, International Institute of Islamic Thought. p. 34.
Cohen, M. R. 2007. Between Crescent and the Cross put the Jews in the Middle Ages. Translated by Islam Islam - Moez Khalfa- wi, I 1, Jamal, Baghdad, p. 154.
Crone, P. and Cook, M. 1977, Hagarism: The Making of the Islamic world. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
David, L., 1999.The Middle east quarterly, Vol. vi: No.3.
George, W., 1988. Moses: Heroic Man, Man of God, A & C Black, p. 29-30.
Gordon, N., 1988. A History of the Jews of Arabia. Univer- sity of California press. P.110.
Hassan, M. K. 1997. The Effects of Orientalist Thought in Islamic Societies. 1, Ain for Human and Social Studies and Re- search, Cairo, p. 21.
Hassan, M. K., 1997. The Effects of Oriental Thought. Ein for human and social studies. p. 23.
Holmberg, B. 2004. Hagarism Revisited. Studia Orientalia. 99, pp. 53-64.
Holy Quran.
Ibn Aboud, M., 1985. The Methodology of Orientalism in the Study of Islamic History, A Study in the Book of Orientalist Curricula in Arab and Islamic Studies, Vol. 1, Arab Organization for Education and Culture, Tunis, 1, pp. 344-345.
Ibn Warraq, 1998. The Origin of the Koran: Classic essays on Islam’s Holy book. Prometheus Books. P. 301.
Leon, N., 1978. Review: Crone-Cook’s Hagarism. The Jew- ish Quarterly Review. Vol. 68, No.3. pp. 179-181.
Oleg, G., 1986. The Illustrations of the “Maqamat”, Specu- lum, Vol. 53, No.4. p.796.
Radhwan, S., 2007. German Orientalists: Development, in- fluence and sources. Islamic thought House. P. 53 (In Arabic).
Stephen, H., 1991. Islamic History. Princeton. P.85.
Zaqzouq, M. H. 1987. Islam in the perceptions of the West. 1, Wahba Library, Egypt, p56.
